One Piece is a manga series that has captivated fans worldwide for over two decades with its intriguing stories, beloved characters, and unexpected plot twists. Recently, a significant event has drawn the attention of the fanbase: the farewell of Carrot from the Straw Hat Pirates, a poignant moment that has been adapted in the anime, closely mirroring a scene from the manga and adding layers to the epic narrative.

In One Piece, Carrot is a member of the Mink Tribe, a race of anthropomorphic animals. She became a fan-favorite character during the Whole Cake Island arc and has spent considerable time traveling with Luffy and the Straw Hat Pirates, contributing significantly to various situations.
Many fans have speculated that Carrot could become a permanent member of the Straw Hat crew, especially after her brave actions and the strong bond she developed with them. However, the manga has left Carrot’s role somewhat ambiguous. During the farewell scene in Wano, Carrot did not appear to say goodbye to the Straw Hats, which led to numerous theories among fans. Some believe that Carrot might still be on Luffy’s ship, preparing to return to Wano at some point, which has drawn significant attention due to the overarching themes and character development intricately crafted by Eiichiro Oda.



However, in episode 1084 of the One Piece anime, this omission from the manga has been rectified. In this episode, the fans finally witnessed a heartfelt farewell as Carrot bid goodbye to the Straw Hats. This addition clarifies her character arc, confirming that she remains in Wano and has not joined the Straw Hat crew.
This correction is significant for several reasons:
- Clarification of Carrot’s Journey: It provides a clearer conclusion regarding Carrot’s journey with the Straw Hats, something that the manga lacked.
- Fan Theories: The correction addresses various theories among fans regarding Carrot’s potential membership in the Straw Hats, which had sparked intense debates within the community.
- Engagement with the Fanbase: It reflects the anime’s responsiveness to the fanbase, often engaging in discussions and addressing speculative theories about the series. This correction can be seen as a gesture of goodwill towards the devoted fans and their passion for the story.