After Avengers: Endgame (2019), Marvel Studios began developing a new superhero universe to replace the original Avengers team. With iconic characters like Captain America and Iron Man being hard to replace after Chris Evans and Robert Downey Jr. became symbols of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), fans were concerned about the new direction. However, Anthony Mackie’s portrayal in Captain America: Brave New World has eased those concerns.
A Deep Dive into the Political Landscape
While recent MCU films have explored cosmic realms, magical elements, and grand battles, Captain America: Brave New World distinctly focuses on political themes and current human issues. The world of the MCU has evolved significantly, especially following the major events in Avengers: Infinity War (2018) and Avengers: Endgame, which left everyone divided.
The Celestial body, which is believed to house the precious metal Adamantium, has become a point of contention among nations. The ongoing conflict and the presence of hired mercenaries raise the stakes, but Thaddeus Ross (Harrison Ford) remains a constant figure, having a complicated relationship with Sam Wilson, also known as Captain America (Anthony Mackie), due to past events involving the Sokovia Accords that split the Avengers in Captain America: Civil War (2016). It can be said that Sam’s experiences differ significantly from those of Steve Rogers (Chris Evans).
The screenplay of Captain America: Brave New World maintains the essence of Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) with a blend of espionage and political intrigue. Sam and his allies must investigate the dark secrets surrounding Thaddeus Ross while simultaneously dealing with the menace posed by the villainous Samuel Sterns (Tim Blake Nelson). The super-soldier serum creates a device capable of controlling minds, making anyone a potential threat to Sam during his mission.
While the pacing of the film is generally good, there are moments where the narrative feels slightly rushed. However, Marvel Studios has been quite “ambitious” in this installment. Many political themes are merely hinted at rather than fully explored, often resembling a “gaze at the flowers.” Sterns’ villainous persona feels somewhat underdeveloped, and there are significant gaps in the plot. The film also presents a geopolitical rivalry between the U.S. and Japan regarding the Celestial source, which feels a bit implausible since Japan has no sovereign rights over this resource.
Alongside this, Captain America: Brave New World faces the challenge of needing viewers to have watched previous Marvel films to fully understand the context. The connecting points include The Incredible Hulk from 2008, the mini-series The Falcon and the Winter Soldier on Disney+, and Eternals (2021). Those who haven’t followed the MCU closely might find themselves lost in the narrative.
Action Sequences Shine, but the Narrative Lacks Depth
Similar to previous installments in the Captain America franchise, the action remains a highlight of Captain America: Brave New World. Sam Wilson’s fighting style differs from that of Steve Rogers, as he does not rely on superhuman strength but instead employs advanced technology, including his Vibranium shield and various gadgets. However, the film’s overall action sequences feel somewhat lacking.
The fight choreography is notably intricate and visually appealing. Sam’s combination of agility and tactical fighting with his shield is inventive. The extended action sequences focus on the immersive experience, with a thrilling rooftop chase that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. However, those who loved the intense hand-to-hand combat of Captain America: The Winter Soldier or the brute strength displayed by Steve Rogers may find this installment lacking in that department.
The action sequences serve as the film’s bright spot, but the narrative feels disjointed due to numerous reshoots and editing issues, affecting character development and pacing. Harrison Ford’s portrayal of Red Hulk seems underutilized, and the character’s arc leaves much to be desired.
Sam Wilson is the New Captain America
The burden of the Captain America title rests not only on Sam Wilson’s shoulders in the film but also on actor Anthony Mackie’s performance. Many fans may initially resist the change, feeling that a person of color taking up the Captain America mantle is a significant shift away from the legacy left by Chris Evans. However, Anthony Mackie has crafted a unique Captain America that stands on its own.
Sam embodies strength without the super-soldier serum, representing the core qualities that made Steve Rogers a hero. His character inspires others to become symbols of hope and leadership in a world that requires resilience. Mackie delivers a commendable performance, portraying the internal struggles and pressures that Sam must navigate.
Actor Danny Ramirez joins the MCU as the new Falcon, portraying a character much like a fanboy fulfilling a dream of becoming a hero. A character with depth, enthusiasm, and humor, he embodies what the MCU needs. Harrison Ford’s Thaddeus Ross adds notable gravitas to the role, with multiple layers of complexity and a constantly evolving persona.
Rating: 3/5
Overall, Captain America: Brave New World is a competent film that delivers a solid introduction of Sam Wilson as the new Captain America and paves the way for the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday (2026). Nonetheless, the expansive nature of the MCU has led to a dilution of its cinematic quality. Filmmakers must tread carefully to avoid sensitive topics while adhering to the established continuity of the franchise.
