The transformation of beloved characters and their representations in live-action adaptations has become a significant trend for Disney, actively applied in various remakes of animated classics. Not only has Ariel’s character undergone a change, but many others, such as Snow White, Belle from Beauty and the Beast, and others, have also experienced this “dark skin transformation.” This phenomenon raises concerns about the integrity of original characters and the strength of contemporary adaptations. Here are five Disney characters from live-action adaptations that have sparked heated discussions on social media:
Ariel the Little Mermaid
Ariel portrayed by Halle Bailey and the character in the original work do not share the same visual traits.
The live-action version of The Little Mermaid was released on May 26 and is currently showing in theaters worldwide.
Since its announcement, the film has continuously stirred debates and controversies, particularly due to the casting of Halle Bailey, an African-American actress, in the lead role of Ariel. Compared to the animated version from 1989, Ariel’s new portrayal not only features a different skin tone but also a more modern hairstyle that deviates from the traditional look of the character.
Online reactions have been mixed about this change. On social media, the hashtag #NotMyAriel has emerged, along with various campaigns opposing the adaptation. Fans of the original character argue that this new depiction does not align with their vision of Ariel.
Belle
Belle also undergoes a skin tone change in the live-action adaptation.
In 2022, Disney released the live-action remake of the beloved musical Beauty and the Beast, starring R&B singer H.E.R. as Belle.
When the actress shared news on Instagram, fans expressed a mix of pride and disappointment, with many stating that it was about time a woman of color was featured prominently. However, some critics noted that Disney continues to cast white actors in leading roles, making the change feel less authentic.
Snow White
The character of “Snow White” has no relation to Rachel Zegler.
In the upcoming live-action version of Snow White, set to premiere in 2024, Rachel Zegler plays the lead role. The 20-year-old Latina star has experience performing on stage and has a powerful singing voice.
However, some fans have expressed dissatisfaction with Zegler’s darker skin tone not matching the description of “white as snow” from the original fairy tale. Critics have even gone so far as to label her portrayal as “the Dark Princess” or “not fitting the character’s description.”
Tinker Bell
In terms of base character design, the animated and live-action versions are similar, aside from skin color.
In early April, Disney released a trailer for the live-action film Peter Pan & Wendy, featuring Tinker Bell portrayed by actress Yara Shahidi.
In this new take, Tinker Bell is characterized as a petite fairy, typically portrayed with blonde hair and fair skin. However, Yara Shahidi brings a different look with her darker skin and hair, leading to mixed reactions online.
The Blue Fairy
The Blue Fairy, originally depicted as having blonde hair and fair skin, has been transformed into a character with darker skin and no hair.
In 2022, Disney released the live-action adaptation of Pinocchio, where the character of the Blue Fairy was played by British actress/singer Cynthia Erivo.
In the animated version, the Blue Fairy shares striking similarities with the fairy godmother from Cinderella. Both characters traditionally sport blonde curls and fair skin. However, Cynthia Erivo’s Blue Fairy not only has darker skin but is also bald, leading to significant backlash regarding this portrayal.
According to HK01
