As the winter anime season of 2023 (from January to March) kicks off, many fans in Japan have expressed that this season is filled with lackluster and uninspired animated films. The truth is, up until now, it seems that their sentiments are justified.
Recently, the popular website MyAnimeList shared a list featuring the highest-rated animated films of the winter 2023 season. The top three entries on this list do not include any newcomers but are instead continuations of previously aired anime series.

At the top of the list is Vinland Saga, Season 2. The first season of this series was a tremendous success, featuring a unique storyline, visually stunning character designs, and excellent animation quality.

The only new entry in the top rankings is The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten, a delightful romantic comedy that has captivated viewers in the West.
First, let’s take a look at the rankings of winter 2023 anime based on ratings:
- Vinland Saga Season 2, 8.80 rating.
- Bungou Stray Dogs Season 4, 8.59 rating.
- DanMachi Season 4 Part 2, 8.04 rating.
- The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten, 7.91 rating.
Next, let’s check the rankings of winter 2023 anime based on the number of followers:
- Vinland Saga Season 2, over 300,000 followers.
- Maou Gakuin no Futekigousha Season 2, over 238,000 followers.
- Tokyo Revengers Season 2, over 214,000 followers.
- Ijiranaide, Nagatoro-san Season 2, over 192,000 followers.

After this ranking was made public, many fans expressed their opinions, stating:
– The ranking of DanMachi as the third-best film of this anime season warrants further discussion.
– I must say, while the first season of Vinland Saga was truly captivating, it’s hard not to continue watching this second part.
– There’s nothing that can compare to Vinland Saga, even though Blue Lock and My Hero Academia have had their own noteworthy moments.
– The rankings lack competition as many films are underwhelming this anime season.